Saturday, February 24, 2024

Dual columns: Should you stay or should you go?

March 19, 2020

With the closure of in-person classes, limited dining hall hours and the need to practice social distancing, many Michigan State students have a choice to make: should I stay or should I go? State News reporters Karly Graham and SaMya Overall detail their experiences and how they came to a decision.


Why I chose to stay on campus

Karly Graham


When I got the email that classes were switching to an all online platform, I knew one thing: I could not go home.

Don't get me wrong. I love my family, it's just really hard to like them sometimes.

Watching my roommate pack up her things and leave was difficult — and so was being told that I would have to work remotely and couldn't spend time with my office buddies. But staying in East Lansing still had more pros than cons.

I really like the freedom I have here. I like that everything I do here is by my own volition. When I'm here, I don't really have to show up to my classes. I still go to all of them (well, now "Zoom" into all of them) with no problems because it is something I am deciding to do.   

Things simply aren't as rewarding when you're asked to do them.  

I really do like spending time at home. I was counting down the days until spring break so I could go home and have a week off, just to be able to lie on the couch and pet my dog. But that's the problem: home is a break.  

Maintaining a good work-life balance is something I don't think I'm able to do from home. I get too easily distracted by my surroundings. Grabbing a cup of coffee when I'm trying to work on something is much more complicated than just walking to the coffee pot and pouring it into a mug.  

It's not that I don't want to go home, it's just that I honestly can't. My family has to work from home now and I wouldn't even be able to move from my room to the kitchen for a class because it will be occupied.  

Now that coffee shops, libraries and diners are closed, I have no solace. On campus, I am able to make my way to a study room if I want a change of scenery. The same can't be said when I'm at home. 

I'm really attached to my life in East Lansing, and I was prepared for it to end in May. I was not ready for it to get cut short by two whole months. 

Yes, I will be leaving before April 12 to get a refund, but I am waiting until that very last weekend before saying goodbye to my second home.   

In my time here at MSU, I have found a greater sense of responsibility, and with that I found a lot more happiness — I wasn't going to take that away from myself by heading home before I needed to. 


Why I chose to return home

Support student media! Please consider donating to The State News and help fund the future of journalism.

SaMya Overall


When Michigan State President Samuel L. Stanley Jr. sent the email that suspended in-person classes, I knew I wanted to continue my classes at home.

Don’t get me wrong, I love being on campus. I enjoy the busyness with students rushing to classes and parties. I like hanging out with my friends in a full dining hall where you have to slightly yell to be heard.

But after Stanley’s announcement, that atmosphere was gone.

Some people were able to leave within a few hours of the announcement. The dining halls were practically empty. My friends were already making arrangements to leave.

The usual hustle and bustle of MSU’s campus became a ghost town, and I knew it was time to leave.

It was disappointing, even before virtual classes were extended to the end of the semester. I knew my freshman year of college was essentially over. However, I knew MSU didn’t need me as much as my family needed me during this time.

Classes were canceled at my sister's school, along with all the other K-12 schools in the state, until early April. My parents were stressed as their jobs began to cut hours and lay people off. I needed to be home to help support them, while trying to finish the semester.

I wish I could say it's been easy, but it hasn’t.

My brain went into rest mode because I was home, and I fell behind. Updating students about COVID-19 and how it is affecting MSU while not being there is more difficult than I anticipated. Not to mention, my Wi-Fi at home is absolutely awful, which makes everything 10 times worse.

But there are upsides. I got to catch up with my sister and spend late nights watching "Hell’s Kitchen." I’m slowly getting the hang of online classes. And I'm able to sleep in a little longer before my morning classes — always a win.

I'm happy with my decision to return home. If anything were to happen, I have the resources to support and protect myself and those around me. I just wouldn’t have that on campus.

It’s unfortunate everything ended so suddenly, and I wish I could spend these last three months on campus. But I know I’m where I need to be.


Share and discuss “Dual columns: Should you stay or should you go?” on social media.