Saturday, March 20, 2010 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us
Feed:
Follow us on:
Mostly Cloudy, 32° F | 0° C
7 day forecast

Article Tools:

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this
  • Add to del.icio.us
  • Blogger
  • Comment feed
  • Print

3-year college plan misses point

(Last updated: 11/19/09 7:08pm)

I rush from class to office hours, then to my counselor, back to class and to work. I don’t sleep for 40 hours in an attempt to get caught up from that one night I spent talking about religion, politics and the English army instead of doing my Mandarin Chinese. I bike in the pouring rain, the cluttered leaves, the freezing temperatures. And I keep getting lost on the Capital Area Transportation Authority buses.

mugshot

Emily Wilkins

And yet, at my core, I love college. I finally have found the perfect balance of freedom and dependence, where I can live for me, not for a college application or a family I must support. And I am well aware I might never be this free again.

College is important for exactly that reason. And I am looking forward to the next three-and-a-half years here. But not everyone is.

A growing trend at colleges across the nation has schools offering students a three-year program for an undergraduate degree. The argument for the change is that it is in tune with the times. Fewer semesters mean less money spent. And for an increasing number of people, this pro will outweighs all other cons.

But those considering skipping a fourth year of college merely for the savings should consider the benefits of taking the time to make the most out of college.

Imagine you’ve been planning to build a house, but for years all you’ve had to plan the project is a pencil and paper. Then one day you’re given a ruler and a calculator. You get to look at samples of the materials, see the actual space where the house will be and maybe talk to someone who can help you build it. You might even get the chance to help build someone else’s home.

I probably don’t have to tell you this is a metaphor for how college can help you prepare for your future by providing you with a greater range of tools. And the more semesters you can spend learning to use the tools, the better off you’ll be.

In the U.S., 20 to 50 percent of college students are no-preference majors. Many who do decide will go on to change their minds. That’s not necessarily a bad thing.

What college students do today will impact the rest of their lives. If a student is on a three-year fast track, they might not have enough time to pursue topics they’re interested in, but do not directly relate to their major.

Students go to college to get a good career. A good career should allow someone to be paid for doing what they love. If a student never has the leeway to explore and define their interests, they might miss the whole point of college. That’s three years of tuition wasted — not just one.

Rushing through college in three years also leaves little time for internships, study abroad programs and real-world experience such as volunteer work. In high school, your grade-point average was the No. 1 factor considered when applying for college. But for professional jobs, hands-on experience is just as important as your GPA.

No, paying for college is not easy — a lesson that is about to become clear to students in the state of Michigan, if it has not already. But simply because one scholarship fell through doesn’t mean there aren’t more out there, and there always are student loans. Those who get them might be paying off the loans for a little longer, but the advantages of an extra year, if used correctly, will outlive the debt.

The overall college experience is one to savor. You are in a community of peers who all are, more or less, at the same stage of their lives. You have the support of your professors, and probably your parents. The responsibilities are few, and those who choose to use this time to their advantage have a definite edge.

The level of freedom you are given has enormous potential and, academics aside, the social life in a college town is one many adults tend to remember fondly, usually with a few laughs and some stories they hesitate to confess to anyone. Love or hate East Lansing, all one has to do is walk down Grand River Avenue to know the businesses who choose to start there are aware of the demographic they’re serving.

The three-year program swings open a door for people who think college is too costly. But that same door can be opened for four years with a little more effort on the part of the student.

Yes, you can save thousands of dollars with the new option, but talk to college students and alums, and chances are you’ll find that last year was worth every penny.

Emily Wilkins is a State News staff writer. Reach her at wilki196@msu.edu.

Originally Published: 11/19/09 7:08pm




PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
Photo courtesy of Wharton Center /

Performers in the traveling professional group Nrityagram perform their tradItional Indian dances.

Powered by reprints.statenews.com.


Commentary:


America

11/19/09 9:51pm

I have no idea why someone would want to rush through college in three years if you don’t have to do so. On one hand, you’re literally giving away the only time in your life where, sure, you have responsibilities — but you can also get go out and get drunk every Thursday. I mean, after college, you at least have to stay in and do so!

And, on the other hand, no one takes a 21-year-old seriously. Or a 25-year-old. Or really anyone in their twenties.

You have plenty of time to worry about paying a mortgage and your kid’s braces — enjoy the time during which these aren’t worries.

America

11/19/09 9:54pm

On a side note, if you’re really worried about money, do your first year or two at a community college. I didn’t do it, but, at this point, I realize that I would’ve gotten an equal or superior education.

3 year grad

11/20/09 10:48am

I think the author misses a key point in her article. Yes, staying in undergrad for an extra year gives you time to take things slower and party more before “real life” but with our current state of things, an undergrad education is usually the first in a long string of degrees before “life”. When most people are looking at masters, phd, md, do, or jd programs, that ‘extra’ year of life experiences in undergrad only amounts to substantially more liver damage and an extra $30,000 in debt to add on to the hundreds of thousands in debt for the grad programs.

Agree with America

11/20/09 1:52pm

I agree if money is a issue going to community college for a year or two is a great idea; and you are right, community colleges offer smaller classes with good instructors, these same classes at MSU will be taught in those massive lecture halls with grad students. While I did not spend a year at community college, I have taken a few courses each summer at one. Those classes in terms of quality blew away any class I ever had at MSU.

It depends

11/22/09 1:28am

While I agree with what the author has to say regarding students experiencing college life, I believe it is up to the individual to decide how many years is enough. Just because you feel that four years seem to be the correct number of years to be in college doesn’t mean that others feel the same way as well.

I personally am going to graduate in 3.5 years with a degree. In between these 3.5 years, I managed to change my major and accumulate so many elective credits because of that that I am graduating with 150 credits.

...

View full comment »