Pontiac - It had been almost two years since Ben Folds Five played at a Michigan venue.
On Sunday night at Clutch Cargos in Pontiac, Ben Folds returned, minus the five.
It was the same sold-out place, the same Baldwin SF-10 piano, mostly the same fans.
The Folds faithful started showing up about 2 p.m. with lawn chairs, even though they couldnt get in until six hours later. Tour Manager Doug Goodman said as of 3 p.m. there were six tickets left, and with a line two blocks long wrapping around the building and adjacent parking lots, even the anticipation and excitement felt the same.
But at 10 p.m., Ben Folds and his new trio of back-up musicians took to the stage, starting with a properly named song that put it all into perspective.
That first song was Not the Same.
For Folds to lead off with that song sent a powerful statement. This concert was different from the piano mans previous Michigan stops.
New material, a more pop-intensive style of music, a guitar, four men on stage, not three.
And Folds seemed happier as he joked with the crowd, gave props to Bob Seger and Ted Nugent, ripped on his publishing company and stomped and thrashed his piano like the good old days. Folds has attributed his new attitude to playing new material and a fresh start following the dismantling of Ben Folds Five in October 2000.
Folds first solo album since Ben Folds Fives demise, Rockin The Suburbs, fell to No. 73 on the Billboard Top 200 album charts in its second week of release. It was a fall of more than 30 spots since it debuted at No. 42 during the week of Sept. 10, but it was evident that all the 1,500 plus in attendance couldnt care less about the discs commercial success.
It seemed Folds didnt either, enthusiastically playing all but one song off of the album and two of its B-sides, Hiros Song and Make Me Mommy.
But as previously mentioned, things were not the same. When he was with Ben Folds Five, the piano was the centerpiece of every song. Without a guitar in the band, Folds had to really let his ivory tickling shine. Now, thanks to a guitar accompaniment, the piano didnt seem as dominant in some of the songs.
Enter the five-song encore.
After closing out his set with the title track of Rockin the Suburbs, Folds re-emerged on stage - alone.
In a scene that was as ghostly as it was beautiful, Folds churned out four classic Ben Folds Five tunes, Kate, Philosophy, One Angry Dwarf and 200 Solemn Faces and Evaporated, the sister song to Ben Folds Fives blockbuster single, Brick. To hear his former bands songs done solo on piano, without any bass or drum accompaniment, was a real treat and showcased the skills that made him one of the most successful pianists in popular music since Billy Joel and Elton John.
And the crowd showed its appreciation for Folds playing of some old (expletive) by filling in for his departed former bandmates and singing all background vocals on the older tunes.
After playing the slow and somber Evaporated, Folds back-up band rejoined him on stage, and the foursome did an impressive rendition of the Ben Folds Five tune, Song for the Dumped, a tale of heartbreak and rejection that was one of the bands more popular songs among its fans.
Frank Maynard, a friend of Folds, runs The Magical Armchair mailing list, a listserve for Ben Folds Five and Ben Folds-related discussion. The Novi resident and MSU alumnus said he is excited by Folds new material and talked with him at the show.
He seemed a lot happier, hes playing all his stuff, hes back on the road, hes out of his publishing contract with Sony and hes playing with good musicians, Maynard said. Theyre like a small circle of friends.
The last time they came to town, (Folds former bandmates Darren Jessee and Robert Sledge) seemed bored, so this is a whole new tour, a whole new band and a whole new start.
Paul Krauss, an English sophomore who has been a fan of Ben Folds Five since 1997, said it was different seeing other musicians playing the older material with Folds, but agreed the tour represents a landmark in Folds career.
I thought Bens new material had a different feel to it, a different vibe, Krauss said. I dont think people were quite as used to it yet. But its good hes going in a different direction, and the more he tours, the more people will get into it, the more people will be more interested in his new stuff instead of the older stuff.