Sunday, March 21, 2010 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us
Feed:
Follow us on:
Mostly Cloudy, 32° F | 0° C
7 day forecast

Article Tools:

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this
  • Add to del.icio.us
  • Blogger
  • Comment feed
  • Print

Simon's stance on transparency commendable

(Last updated: 11/08/09 10:09pm)

Recently, the State News editorial board had the opportunity to sit down with MSU President Lou Anna K. Simon and discuss a number of issues pertaining to campus.

One of the most notable things that came out of the meeting was the larger matter of transparency between the administration and students, especially regarding how MSU is dealing with major challenges in terms of its budget.

The uproar and controversy last year that surrounded the elimination of MSU’s music therapy program illustrated the perils of nontransparency, and it’s likely the administration learned a valuable lesson from that saga. Now, the university says it has adopted a model of transparency in its budget deliberations, and has even debuted a new Shaping the Future Web site to prove it.

But even in a supposed “transparent” administration, there have been more than a few hiccups as of late.

For instance, the university might have been frustrated with The State News for breaking the story about the administration’s proposed plan to move Olin Health Center to the MSU Clinical Center on Service Road. It might say we jumped the gun and that releasing the story led to unnecessary worries among the Olin staff and student body. But as a news-gathering organization, we can’t just sit around until everything is laid out in a neat little plan, especially when those issues affect student welfare.

Although it’s true all of these changes still only are in the “proposed” stage, it’s important that students know what’s at stake and make their voices heard as the university hammers out its budget.

During our meeting, Simon made the comment that she would be upset if students didn’t make their voices heard in many ways, and welcomes input from students — it just depends what format in which that input comes.

The best way for students to make their views known is to engage directly with university officials through the Shaping the Future Web site, Simon said. Facebook groups are all well and good, but usually they are just a way for students to vent and don’t often result in real change. Students can’t simply whine in their own social networks of choice and expect that they’ll be taken seriously. Whether it be opposition to moving Olin or an effort to save their own major from a moratorium, students must talk to the administration and not simply grumble amongst themselves.

We appreciate the university choosing to be more open with students and the general public, but instead of trying to convince the university of our point of view, we also would like to see and hear more of the university’s arguments and reasoning on why they believe certain measures are in the best interest of MSU. It’s one thing to make data and documents available to the public, but it’s another to publicize this fact and invite people to scrutinize it and offer suggestions. We would prefer more emphasis on the latter.

The university needs to go out to the people; it can’t expect the people to come to them. The new Shaping the Future Web site, which can be found at www.shapingthefuture.msu.edu, is a welcome first step, but the university needs to publicize it more so that students can use it the way it was intended — as tool to inform and engage the MSU community.

We hope the university continues to practice what it preaches regarding transparency, and that the larger MSU community will respond to MSU’s gesture with informed suggestions.

It might be messy for a while, but it’s our hope that by engaging both sides, the MSU administration, its students and the greater MSU community can come together and keep MSU strong throughout these tough times.

Originally Published: 11/08/09 7:22pm




PHOTOS OF THE WEEK:More reprints »
Photo courtesy of Wharton Center /

Performers in the traveling professional group Nrityagram perform their tradItional Indian dances.

Powered by reprints.statenews.com.


Commentary:


student

11/08/09 8:09pm

As a student who supports Pres. Simon, Provost Wilcox and the rest of the administration, I have to say that this transparency has been always present since Pres. Simon took over. Simon is a person that really loves MSU, she works hard for the University and really knows the history of MSU. Furthermore, she works to sustain the Land Grant mission and to increase quality of MSU.

I think that MSU is in a historical moment where it has reunited the most amount of leaders in history to really move forward, change the mindset and increase the quality of Michigan State University.

...

View full comment »

Actual Student

11/08/09 9:25pm

If they are so transparent then why aren’t the actual reccomendation letters to the provost that were a result of the shaping the future website not made available to the public….. Also, the rumors are that Olin is moving next fall, I’ll bet that it is the same change that was originally proposed by the administration this past summer.

Another real student

11/09/09 1:39pm

What a load. If the process has been so transparent, why were students and faculty not made privy to the discussions occurring before these cuts were recommended?

Why have they not been provided with numbers to demonstrate that the cuts being proposed are going to have a positive impact?

Why are students and faculty not being invited to suggest their own potential solutions, and to review the administration’s budget for areas where that might be cut?

Michigan State University is rapidly turning into East Lansing Community College.

student

11/09/09 3:15pm

First, Board of Trustees meetings have always been public. The fact that you don’t receive an invitation doesn’t mean anything.

Second, everything is posted online. Again, the fact that you don’t receive the documents in your mail doesn’t mean that they haven’t made public.

http://www.msu.edu/thisismsu/board_admin/index.html

Between the pages for the Board of Trustees, Budgets and Finance I think you will be able to find all the info you want there.

As I said, the key here is that if you have less money you can’t sustain the same level of productivity because simply there’s not enough.

...

View full comment »

Another real student

11/09/09 3:55pm

Yes, I am well aware of the material that is available to the public, as well as the public nature of the Board of Trustees meeting. I attended the last one. As for the material online, it is only made available after it has been presented. Which of course, means that decisions are already being made without the input of faculty or students (or staff, for that matter), who are the very individuals most affected by them.

...

View full comment »

student

11/09/09 5:36pm

I disagree, again.

First, most of the documents, including the minutes of the Board, are posted before each meeting. That’s why is possible for The State News to release the articles before the meetings regarding what is going to be discussed. The thing is that people don’t necessarily look where they should. The Shaping the Future website is a new addition to have fellow members of the MSU community to understand what is trying to get accomplished, the decisions, the timeline, etc.

...

View full comment »

Dr. Simon

11/09/09 11:33pm

Nothing gets me up in the morning like advancing indoctrination and transforming minds. Diversity is my religion. Nothing says higher education like different colored people self segregating among the faculty and students. I love my job.

Engaging Directly?

11/10/09 9:31am

One of the ways to officially “engage directly” with the MSU Administration is to speak at the Board of Trustees meetings. However, as anyone who has ever been to a BOT meeting can attest, President Simon and a significant number of the Board can often be found having side conversations, checking their email, and perusing various documents during the public comments.

...

View full comment »