In response to the studies presented this week on the positive effects of the tailgating restrictions ("Tailgate trash" SN 1/25), I fear there may be negative effects that are not being studied.

It was obvious during the final few tailgating weekends that tailgating has not disappeared, as proponents to the new rules would like to portray. The tailgating has simply moved into the neighborhoods surrounding campus. Although I do not have statistics to support my statements - no studies have been launched on this theory - it is my opinion that more problems with East Lansing may arise due to the new rules.

Many students had parties on their front lawns, as opposed to on campus, to thwart the new rules. With neighborhood relationships already strained, I fear that this may lead to bigger problems, including noise violations, increased minor consumption, and increased trash in the city.

The beauty of tailgating was that it was a contained party with clear boundaries. Police knew where to patrol and campus workers were there to clean up the mess. With the tailgaters moving off campus, the police will be scattered throughout the city and no one will be responsible to pick up after the alumni and students.

Before we praise the results and extend these rules, I hope that all involved take a hard look at the potential issues these new rules will create.

Tim Brumbaugh
2002 Graduate