Monday, May 13, 2024

Letter: Cultural Appropriation is misleading and not an issue

November 3, 2015

Editor's note: The following letter does not reflect upon the overall opinion of The State News. 

As Halloween came and went, I found it hard to not notice all the attention placed on the taste of a person’s costume.

Many articles and discussions were held discouraging costumes that exemplified cultural icons, at least for those who did not share that culture. Showing up at a costume party in an Indian headdress, a kimono, or as Pocahontas were just a few examples I was given on “cultural appropriation” — the latest term coined by the fervent "politically correct police" sweeping our nation.

This refers to the negative phenomena circling around adapting the cultures (clothing, songs, and sometimes vernacular language) or other people whom you yourself do not belong. Many commentators on the subject point to said perpetrators as “racist” and uncaring of others, and their reasons for doing so cannot be valid.

Is cultural appropriation really such a bad thing? Fact is, cultural identities are not as black-and-white as they seem. Centuries of melting pot culture in the United States have ingrained words, food, and dress into our country that we all enjoy. 

The line between cultures here is blurred constantly. Are you appropriating Asian culture by enjoying Chinese food? Listening to reggae? Singing rap music? Most would say no. Then why do we draw the line at Halloween costumes? A vast majority of those who go out dressed as Indians do not do so with disregard for Indian culture or history, but rather respect for what Indian headdresses and garments signify. 

Calling out our peers as perpetrators of cultural appropriation, as though it is racist to do so, is not necessarily fair in this context. I believe this is evident in our era of oversensitivity; it seems these days just about anything can offend anyone.

The term cultural appropriation is in itself misleading. To “appropriate” would imply something is stolen, and when it is stolen, it cannot be taken back. Culture is not a physical object and cannot be taken in such a way. Especially today, when we all experience a myriad of cultural indentities in our daily life, does cultural appropriation seem less like fact and more of a myth created by our politically correct society.

I believe this needs to be changed. Rather than vilifying others of cultural appropriation, we should appreciate the cultures and experiences of our peers and be proud it is something we can celebrate. 

It is my hope “cultural appreciation” becomes the new norm by next Halloween.

Derek Hackett is a political theory and constitutional democracy sophomore. He can be reached at hacket21@msu.edu.


A previous version of this letter read "It is my hope “cultural appropriation” becomes the new norm by next Halloween." The writer of this piece said he meant to put "appreciation."

Support student media! Please consider donating to The State News and help fund the future of journalism.

Discussion

Share and discuss “Letter: Cultural Appropriation is misleading and not an issue” on social media.