Spartans lose 2nd straight, 42-34 to Minnesota
By Matt Bishop (Last updated: 11/01/09 11:31pm)Minneapolis — It was a frightful night for the MSU football team at TCF Bank Stadium on Saturday.
In a Halloween matchup with Minnesota, the Spartans allowed more than 500 yards of total offense and allowed Minnesota to overcome a school-record 17 penalties in a 42-34 loss to the Golden Gophers.
“We didn’t play well enough to win and that starts with me,” MSU head coach Mark Dantonio said. “(We were) outcoached. They had their guys ready to play. I thought we were ready but obviously we were not.”
The game could not have gotten off to a worse possible start for the Spartans, as Minnesota was up 14-0 before MSU (4-5 overall, 3-3 Big Ten) even ran an offensive play.
On the first play from scrimmage, Minnesota quarterback Adam Weber found running back Duane Bennett wide open down the left sideline for a 66-yard touchdown.
On the ensuing kickoff, freshman running back Edwin Baker was stripped, setting the Golden Gophers up at the MSU 28-yard line.
After a holding penalty pushed them back, Weber threw a perfect ball on third-and-19 to receiver Brandon Green for a 37-yard touchdown to put Minnesota (5-4, 3-3) up 14-0 less than two minutes into the game.
A fumbled snap gave Minnesota prime field position again, but the Spartans defense was able to force Minnesota to punt.
On the next drive, MSU drove 87 yards in 13 plays but had to settle for a 20-yard field goal by senior kicker Brett Swenson after gaining only one yard in three tries from the 4-yard line.
Minnesota started a drive down the field but it ended abruptly as Weber was intercepted by senior linebacker Brandon Denson near midfield after his receiver ran into the umpire.
Denson’s return plus a 15-yard facemask penalty put the Spartans in prime position at the Minnesota 26-yard line. On third-and-10, Cousins scrambled, ran in a circle while barely avoiding crossing the line of scrimmage, turned and found sophomore tight end Brian Linthicum wide open for a 26-yard touchdown to bring the Spartans within four, 14-10.
“I didn’t feel like my receiver was open to get us a first down, so I just tried to reverse field and didn’t feel anybody there and when I looked back around, Brian had gotten behind the defense and was open,” Cousins said.
The Spartans got the ball back after a Minnesota punt and Dantonio decided to go to sophomore quarterback Keith Nichol with the ball inside the MSU 10. The Spartans quickly went three-and-out and with good field position, the Gophers went ahead 21-10 on a 7-yard touchdown pass from Weber to tight end Nick Tow-Arnett.
MSU appeared to grab the momentum to start the second half as sophomore receiver Keshawn Martin returned the opening kick 93 yards to bring MSU within four, 21-17. It was MSU’s first kick return touchdown since Demond Williams took one back against Indiana in 2005.
But it only took the Gophers five plays to retake their 11-point lead as Bennett plunged in from 1-yard out.
Minnesota appeared to be knocking on the door step again after quarterback MarQueis Gray went out inside the 5-yard line, but a holding penalty brought the play back. After two false start penalties dropped the Gophers back further, Minnesota punted.
On the first play of the next drive, Martin struck again, taking an end-around 84 yards for a touchdown, bringing MSU back with four, 28-24.
Minnesota appeared to be ready to score again after a 71-yard kick return, but MSU’s defense stood firm, dropping the Gophers back 13 yards in the first two plays. An illegal shift penalty sent them back five more yards and after an incompletion, kicker Eric Ellestad’s 48-yard field goal was wide right.
After Minnesota fumbled deep in its own territory on its next drive, Cousins found freshman tight end Dion Sims in the end zone for an 11-yard touchdown as time expired on the third quarter. Swenson’s extra point gave the Spartans their first lead of the game 31-28.
But it was short lived as Minnesota charged right back, going 73 yards in six plays, capped by a 2-yard touchdown toss from Weber to Tow-Arnett. Tow-Arnett set career highs in receptions, yards and touchdowns in the game.
“They had a measured response every time we got back in it and I think that’s good coaching and good execution,” Dantonio said. “We stopped the run but we couldn’t stop the pass.”
On the next drive, MSU was aided by two 15-yard Minnesota personal fouls. A 19-yard pass from Cousins to sophomore receiver B.J. Cunningham got the Spartans down to the 1-yard line. Senior fullback Andrew Hawken was stopped for a loss of one on first down, Baker for no gain on second down and Cunningham was just out of bounds on a fade from Cousins, setting up a 20-yard field goal by Swenson to make it 35-34 Gophers with 8:10 remaining.
On the ensuing drive, Denson appeared to force Tow-Arnett to fumble, but upon further review, the play was reversed and called incomplete. On the next play, Weber threw to Tow-Arnett and Tow-Arnett fell back-first to the ground after being hit by junior cornerback Chris L. Rucker, but he never officially had possession of the ball and it popped out right into the arms of Bennett, who finished the 59-yard play for a touchdown, putting Minnesota up eight with less than six minutes to go.
“I was right there, (Tow-Arnett) was down,” junior lineback Greg Jones said. “That’s how I feel about it. They made the call and that’s it.”
MSU got the ball back and drove down. MSU had fourth-and-14 from the 39-yard line, but Cousins’ pass to Linthicum down the seam was broken up with 3:18 to go.
“We had our chances on that drive and a couple miscues, a couple missed assignments and that’ll happen,” Cousins said. “That was a reflection of the day. We did some good things but we didn’t play disciplined football enough to win.”
The Spartans forced Minnesota to punt on fourth-and-1 with less than 2:30 to go, but senior Kendell Davis-Clark was whistled for running into the kicker, giving the Gophers a first down with 2:13 to go and MSU with no timeouts.
The Gophers picked up the win despite picking up a school-record 17 penalties for 157 yards, also a school record.
Weber finished the day with 416 yards and five touchdowns for Minnesota. Cousins finished with 236 yards and two touchdowns.
“We never got the pressure that we’d been getting in previous games, consistent pressure,” Dantonio said. “We did not play the deep ball well enough.”
Dantonio cited his team’s lack of consistency on both sides of the ball as a major reason for the loss.
“We got hurt in every phase of the game,” he said.
The Spartans return to action next week at noon Saturday in a nonconference game against Western Michigan.
Originally Published: 10/31/09 11:45pm
















student
10/31/09 11:48pmAs an MSU and Big Ten fan, I can’t express enough disappointment on the way the referees are calling the game and the overuse of penalties in the games. I just finished watching the MSU-UMinn game and it was a complete disappointment because the referees didn’t let the players decide the game. First, they called a ridiculous amount of unnecessary penalties on both teams and then they overturned and confirmed plays that, clearly, the video showed that the decision had to be the opposite.
...View full comment »
MSU31
10/31/09 11:56pmI’m beginning to think that the Big Ten refs are completely incompetent. I watched all of the Big Ten’s games today, and all of them were plagued with ridiculous over-turned or “confirmed” plays that you’d have to be high AND stupid to agree with. How these refs can make these calls with a straight face is beyond me. Are they consulting a magic 8 ball when they review plays, or actually watching replays?
Spartan Fan
11/01/09 12:00amRobbed once again due to pinpointable blatantly erronous calls to give the opposing team another chance.
Tony
11/01/09 12:11amLets not blame the refs for another week of the “Pat Narduzzi calls ridiculous plays while Mark Dantonio pouts on the sideline” show.
Disgraceful. Now it’s going to take a miracle to even get into the Little Ceasar’s pizza bowl.
If you score 34 points, you should win. If you score 34 points, and the other team has a school record number of penalties, you really should win…unless of course, your defensive coordinator has no sense of pattern recognition. Then you’re just doomed.
MSU31
11/01/09 12:15amI know! Let’s run it up the middle on 1st, 2nd, and 3rd and goal!
11/01/09 12:31amThat bs interception pull back followed by the time where the player landed on his back, then threw it to his teammate? I agree on the play calling starting to seem redundant but that was some major BS reffing!
mimi
11/01/09 12:32amok seriously lets not even try to say anything about the reffs….when you let a team go up 14 in less than 2 minutes, get 17penalties for 157 yards in your favor and still lose it is your own fault……..how bad does it feel to be an offensive player on this team, you have one of the best offenses in the league and the defense continues to blow it for you
Does Anyone Practice?
11/01/09 12:39amAren’t you supposed to practice goal line plays that work? If your quarterback can’t sneek and your halfback can’t run or JUMP OVER!!!, then at least you can bootleg with a slant route with a high percentage of success!!! What’s going on Spartans???
Allen
11/01/09 12:46amare we talkin’ bout practice?
Does Anyone Practice?
11/01/09 12:51am…I give up
419 Passing Yards
11/01/09 1:17amThe safeties are fired, goodbye. Put two moderately fast white dudes with brains in the safety positions (don’t care if they can tackle, at all), just as long as they can constistently LOOK at the ball, BAT it DOWN, and intercept it ONCE per game.
Thank you.
Affirmin' da Action
11/01/09 1:26amooba deba, i be da ref in da big 10, tanks affirmin’ da action!
D EK
11/01/09 10:17amWINNERS PLAY TO WIN! LOSERS PLAY TO LOSE!
sad
11/01/09 10:33amits a sad season for us, no doubt about that. I really do have to wonder at some of the calls. Especially in the red zone. What the hell is up with that?
Chemist
11/01/09 12:19pmThe season is over after the very first three games of the season for the Spatans. How disappointing ! ! ! The last two games were just insults to injury. Give credit to the Gophers some credit. They fought from the very beginning with smart plays and solid defense. I could not say the same thing for our team.
chris
11/01/09 12:50pmyou sone of a bitch why did you lose
David
11/01/09 3:54pmHas anybody else noticed that after Dantonio left Cincinnati THEIR program got better? Ours? oh, about the same, second tier football in a second tier conference. Central Michigan is the best program in the State. Bo and Biggie must be twirling in their sarcaphagi.
Lee
11/02/09 9:57amI agree with MSU31 (as well as many other comments here). We CANâT keep running up the middle and wasting our first and second downs!
Pat Narduzzi deserves every bit of criticism that heâs getting â if you told any sane person that one team scored 34 and the other team was penalized 17 times for 157 yards, theyâd guess that the first team won the game.
HOWEVER, Treadwell needs to own up to this mess, too.
...View full comment »
omega watches
11/13/09 10:08pmhttp://www.wholewatches.com/rolex-watches.html
http://www.wholewatches.com/breitling-watches.html