Monday, March 22, 2010 | Since 1909 | East Lansing, MI Advertise | Classifieds | Puzzles | Employment | Contact Us
Feed:
Follow us on:
Mostly Cloudy, 32° F | 0° C
7 day forecast

Article Tools:

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Digg this
  • Add to del.icio.us
  • Blogger
  • Comment feed
  • Print

CIty needs to do more work to increase road safety

(Last updated: 10/04/09 7:53pm)

At the beginning of the semester, an MSU student was hit by a vehicle while riding her bicycle across the Michigan Avenue and Harrison Road intersection. The police said it was her fault.

I won’t try to quarrel with laws that treat bicycles as vehicles, but the fact is, this is a dangerous intersection for cyclists, pedestrians and motorists alike. And the fact is I have been complaining about the danger to city and state governments for the past 25 years, but nothing has been done — unless you want to count coming up with a pie in the sky 100-year vision for a Michigan Avenue corridor.

Of course, the underlying problem is that many motorists don’t bother to look for pedestrians or cyclists at any intersection, let alone yield right of way, even when right of way clearly belongs to those on foot or bicycle. And some pedestrians and cyclists are guilty of paying insufficient attention or of trying to assert right of way, legal or not, in the face of unyielding traffic.

But the Michigan Avenue and Harrison Road intersection has an additional problem that makes it needlessly extra dangerous, a problem that could be fixed for no cost if there was someone competent enough in city or state government to fix it.

The pedestrian walk sign for crossing Michigan Avenue is mistimed, and has been for years and years. This gives misleading information to pedestrians and vehicles about how much time there is to cross and who has right of way, which inevitably leads to confusion and games of chicken.

The northbound traffic light stays green for 34 seconds. The walk sign lasts 4 seconds, blinks “Don’t Walk” for 15 seconds, then turns “Don’t Walk” for the final 15 seconds of the cycle. It only takes about 20 seconds to walk the whole way across at a relatively slow three miles-per-hour pace, but even a jogger ends up crossing the second part from the median against a blinking “Don’t Walk.”

Maybe authorities actually expect pedestrians to wait at the median for a second cycle, because they imagine asking vehicles to yield would cause traffic congestion (it wouldn’t!). But the reality is pedestrians ignore the walk sign for the simple reason that it is stupid, which every new Brody freshman learns within a week. I’ve crossed against the light with, among others, a city councilwoman and a judge, not to mention parents with impressionable children.

Sadly, even if the politicians and bureaucrats have a sudden attack of common sense and fix the timing of the walk signal, and make some other minor safety improvements, this will remain a dangerous intersection. My advice, whether walking, biking or driving, is: Pay attention! Be careful out there!

_Eliot Singer,
East Lansing resident_

Originally Published: 10/04/09 7:49pm




Commentary:


Chris Wolf

10/05/09 2:22pm

I don’t think this walk signal is mistimed. The traffic signal at this intersection is phased in a way that makes the walk-signal timing necessary.

The “Walk” light comes on at the same time that the north- and south-bound traffic lights turn green (as you would expect). After about 19 seconds, the southbound traffic signal turns red, while the northbound traffic signal remains green and gets an additional green arrow for unrestricted left turns onto Michigan Avenue.

...

View full comment »

John McDaniel

10/05/09 10:22pm

Clarification: The accident you reference actually took place in the east-west pedestrian crossing located just south of the Kellogg Center.

Your ending comments apply to this crosswalk as well as the Michigan Ave. – Harrison intersections, and many others around campus – walking, biking or driving – pay attention.

Erin

10/05/09 10:57pm

I live near this intersection and I have crossed it many times and never noticed any danger in the timing. You say that maybe they expect people to stop at the median and wait for another walk sign like that is just such a preposterous idea. That’s what I do and I’ve seen others do that as well. If you are on sidewalk, out of the way of oncoming traffic and it’s a blinking red, it means don’t cross.

...

View full comment »